Use Sophia to knock out your gen-ed requirements quickly and affordably. Learn more
×

Generating Alternative Solutions

Author: Sophia

what's covered
In this lesson, you will focus on the second step in the problem-solving process: generating solutions to a problem. You’ll also explore a common pitfall to avoid when generating solutions as a group.

Specifically, this lesson will cover:
  1. Problem-Solving Process
  2. Generating Solutions
    1. What to Do
    2. What to Avoid

1. Problem-Solving Process

In the previous lesson, you learned about the four steps of the problem-solving process.

  1. Recognize the problem
  2. Generate solutions
  3. Evaluate solutions
  4. Implement solutions
the steps of the problem solving process: (one) recognize the problem, (two) generate solutions, (three) evaluate solutions, (four) implement solutions

Once you recognize you have a problem, it is time to start thinking about potential solutions. This second step of the process is all about brainstorming to come up with as many potential solutions as possible. During this stage, it is important that you use your self- and social awareness skill to avoid shutting down valid ideas prematurely.

before you start
Before you begin section 2, think about your own problem-solving process. Do you always consider all options? Are you open-minded and willing to try out new approaches? How much time do you take to brainstorm and think about potential solutions before you determine the best course of action?

term to know

Brainstorming
A technique of getting a group together to share ideas and information in an effort to solve a problem.

2. Generating Solutions

When it comes to generating solutions, there are things you want to do and things you want to avoid. Paying attention to both is equally important to ensure you work toward the best possible solutions.

2a. What to Do
There is a lot of value in brainstorming and judgment-free thinking when developing potential solutions to a problem. By valuing diversity and different ways of thinking, you can cultivate new and fresh ideas. This second step of the problem-solving process (Generate Solutions) is all about being open to any idea. You will consider how it might be implemented or if it could cause any issues in step three of the process. The focus of this second step is to come away with a list of potential solutions, not any single one you intend to use.

There are many ways you can brainstorm and come up with ideas. One acronym that can help you in this process is DOVE:

Defer judgment: List any and all ideas. Write everything down.

Offbeat or original: Try to come up with out-of-the-box ideas and solutions.

Vast number: List as many ideas as possible.

Expand or elaborate: Be more specific about each item listed, but do not evaluate any ideas at this stage.

You want to keep these key points in mind whether you are working on a problem yourself or as part of a group. It is also useful for both personal and professional problems.

a group of co-workers having a discussion about a holiday event with planning materials spread out in front of them

EXAMPLE

Cara was tasked with finding a way to cut $500 from the budget for her company's annual holiday party. She immediately thought she could just change the type of food she was ordering, but then she remembered her supervisor was particular about the menu. She asked two of her colleagues to meet her to discuss potential solutions. They met in the conference room and used the whiteboard to capture their thoughts. They set a time limit of 15 minutes to share as many ideas as they could. They ended up with a list of 15 options. They spent the next 30 minutes adding details to make sure each idea was clear to everyone. At the end of the 45 minutes they had enough detail to move to step three of the problem-solving process - Evaluation.

DOVE is just one example of how you can approach brainstorming. You can find more ideas if you search “brainstorming techniques” on the Internet. The main goal is the same in all cases: to generate as much as you can without judging or thinking too much about what it would look like once put into practice. Be creative and make sure you use some method so you have a visual of everything you come up with.

try it
Check out this article from the Indeed Career Guide that shares 25 brainstorming techniques. Think about a problem you are facing. It can be at home, work, or school. Choose one of the brainstorming techniques from the list to capture potential solutions to your problem. You may use paper and pencil or a computer application such as Microsoft Word or Google Docs.

No matter which technique you use, there are some general rules you want to keep in mind as you work:

  1. Keep an open mind.
  2. Refrain from judging ideas while brainstorming.
  3. Encourage unusual and creative ideas.
  4. The more ideas suggested, the better.
  5. Make sure everyone has a chance to contribute ideas.
  6. Take turns talking.
  7. Stay on topic while still making the session fun.
These seven rules build on DOVE and should be kept in mind during any brainstorming. By following these rules, you will be more productive and they will help ensure that you don’t miss out on a great idea by judging it prematurely or unfairly.

2b. What to Avoid
key concept
If you have a large and diverse group of people brainstorming for solutions to a problem, it's important to avoid the tendencies of groupthink.

Groupthink is a theory that was developed by social psychologist Irving Janis in 1972 and it states that groups with members who are overly concerned with conformity have poor judgment when it comes to decisions made by that group. In other words, the group makes faulty decisions because the members are so intent on reaching a consensus that they don’t voice their doubts or dissenting opinions (Janis, 1972). When it comes to groupthink situations, people go along with the group’s decision even when they don’t agree.

The problem with groupthink is that the decisions made under those circumstances ignore important information and are—at the very least—less than ideal. For example, consider a jury panel that has people from the same backgrounds. If that jury panel is sequestered for a murder trial and there is a great deal of pressure within the group to reach a unanimous verdict soon so that everyone can go home, then groupthink is more likely to occur. The consequences of groupthink in that situation are serious for the person who is on trial because the decision that is being made is not likely to be based on rational judgment.

Having diversity in group settings reduces the likelihood of groupthink happening. That is because the group members with different backgrounds and beliefs can bring unique and creative ideas that will benefit the decision-making process of the group.

terms to know

Groupthink
A theory that outlines how group pressure to conform leads to faulty decision-making in groups.
Consensus
Agreement.
Dissenting
Differing or conflicting.
summary
In this lesson, you learned more about the second step of the problem-solving process. You looked in detail at the generating solutions step and how brainstorming can help you with the process. You also considered how groupthink can hinder your progress. You focused on the importance of capturing all ideas—no matter how different or creative.

REFERENCES

Janis, I. L. (1972). Victims of groupthink: A psychological study of foreign-policy decisions and fiascos. Houghton Mifflin.

Terms to Know
Brainstorming

A technique of getting a group together to share ideas and information in an effort to solve a problem.

Consensus

Agreement.

Dissenting

Differing or conflicting.

Groupthink

A theory that outlines how group pressure to conform leads to faulty decision-making in groups.