Use Sophia to knock out your gen-ed requirements quickly and affordably. Learn more
×

Formulating a Thesis

Author: Sophia

what's covered
In this lesson, you will explore how to move from your research question to a thesis statement. Specifically, this lesson will cover:

Table of Contents

1. Research Question to Thesis Statement

In the previous lesson, we explored the process of open-ended research to narrower research driven by a question you want to answer. The next goal is to use the answers to your research question(s) to formulate a thesis statement.

A thesis statement is the main idea for your essay, to which all the paragraphs in the paper should relate. A thesis statement is more than a topic. Thesis statements let your reader know what to expect from the rest of the essay. The thesis statement usually appears at the end (or near the end) of the first paragraph and is often a single sentence, but a thesis can also be a short group of sentences.

Your thesis statement is often the most important sentence in the essay because it summarizes your main position (or claim) and identifies the main components (or subclaims) of your argument. There are some basic conditions for a successful thesis statement:

  • Your thesis statement takes a debatable position on a topic, which means that reasonable people can disagree with (or at least doubt) your position.
  • Your thesis statement is specific so that the reader is clear about what you are arguing or claiming.
  • Your thesis statement should be the right scale of depth to match the assignment. For this course, you will need to be able to sustain an argument that is 5–8 pages long. The scale of your thesis is different than the thesis for a book-size argument.
  • Your thesis statement should be supportable. A good thesis statement is something you can support with evidence and analysis. Your audience should be able to see where you are going, and that you can get there through hints about your subclaims or supporting points.
try it
Rate each of the following thesis statements according to the criteria that the thesis statement be supportable, debatable, and specific.
Parents should limit screen time and encourage their children to engage in other activities.
This statement is not clear or specific because the term “limit” would suggest different things to different people. It is also not debatable, since few would argue that parents should give their children unlimited screen time (except maybe kids!).
Parents should use apps to control kids’ usage of screens so they can teach them appropriate limits on screen usage.
This statement is more specific, proposing a solution to the problem. It is also debatable because some parents might argue that kids only learn to control their screen time if they control their own screen time! There is still some ambiguity about what “limit” means.


By practicing the skill of writing a thesis statement, you will also grow in your ability to think critically, argue effectively, and organize your ideas. These skills are all essential skills for both personal success and professional growth. Being able to state your point clearly and concisely is a skill that applies to speaking, writing emails, giving presentations, or explaining ideas to others.

EXAMPLE

During a job interview, you might have to answer questions like, “Tell me about yourself,” or “Why should we hire you?” In your response, you’re essentially providing a thesis statement, or a clear claim about your strengths, supported by examples.


2. Strategies for Developing a Thesis Statement

The frame for a thesis statement refers to the basic structure or formula that helps writers clearly express the main point or argument of their essay or piece of writing. A strong thesis statement provides both what the writer is arguing and how or why they are arguing it. If you are struggling to put your thesis statement into words, consider using a strategy or frame.

watch
In this video, you'll learn more about how to draft a working thesis statement, and revise your ideas into a final thesis statement.

2a. Problem/Solution

Perhaps the most common approach is to propose a solution to a problem. This is the best way to get from a non-debatable position to one that is debatable—everybody probably agrees that something like crime, pollution, or littering is a problem, but they disagree about the solution.

EXAMPLE

People are understandably reluctant to subsidize drug use or supplying addicts with drugs, but “safe supply” campaigns reduce crime and—if administered correctly—compel users to interact with addiction specialists who can help.

You might also flip this and show that a widely accepted “solution” to a problem is ineffective, and that resources should be spent elsewhere.

EXAMPLE

Programs that expose juvenile offenders to prison life in the hope of “scaring them straight” are ineffective at best and traumatizing at worst.

2b. Cause/Effect

This is close to the problem/solution model because revealing the cause behind a problem can be the first step toward a solution.

EXAMPLE

Family counseling for juvenile offenders curbs future incidents better than punitive measures like incarceration.

However, cause/effect might also be about positive outcomes.

EXAMPLE

Reading to your children every night for 20 minutes improves literacy, emotional growth, and your own relationship with your child.

2c. Drawing a Conclusion From Available Evidence

Another common form of academic argument is asserting a claim where the absolute truth is not known, such as historical theses about events of the past or criminal investigations that try to match a potential suspect to all of the available evidence.

EXAMPLE

With DNA analysis and other evidence, we now know that Walter Sickert is the most likely man behind the infamous “Jack the Ripper” murders.

As with the other structures, the thesis may be more about disproving a misconception than establishing a fact.

EXAMPLE

Medieval Europe had more economic mobility than past histories and historical fiction suggest.

If your thesis statement relies on this kind of claim, you must be sure that the claim can be true or false, not an opinion.


3. Working Thesis Into a Final Thesis

There are two phases of the thesis statement with two different purposes:

  • The first phase is for the person doing the writing. This thesis statement helps clarify for themself what they hope to do in the essay and guides them through the writing process. This is the working thesis. This is where we’re at now in the writing process, and what all of the examples in this tutorial have been.
  • The second phase and purpose are to tell readers what the paper is about. This thesis statement gives the author’s purpose and provides an overview of the supporting evidence for their claim. This is the final thesis.
When you first form your thesis, you might have a good idea of what your support for your argument will be, but it’s actually good practice to wait until you are further along with your research to finalize your thesis statement. You don’t want to limit yourself to three specific supporting points because you might discover an even better supporting argument. Furthermore, you don’t want to commit to a supporting argument that turns out to be weak or flawed.

IN CONTEXT
The Evolution of a Working Thesis Into a Final Thesis

Raina has come up with this working thesis:

Our department store should add game-like elements and rewards to the employee app to improve employee engagement.

As she furthers her research, she can refine this to include the three main areas of support that will follow.

Our department store should add game-like elements to the employee app to improve employee engagement, as studies show employees in such programs feel more accountable for their time, more recognized for their accomplishments, and more positive about their relationships with management.

While her original thesis proposed that the tool would help retain staff, she can’t find any sources that support that argument, at least not directly. So, she has mentally revised her thesis to short-term benefits of the program and hopes that readers will see the potential for long-term benefits.

Similarly, you may have a few ideas in mind and even incorporate them into your working thesis statement but remember that the thesis statement will continue to evolve as you do research, particularly as you create your outline. Remember that writing and research are closely connected, each aiding the other. In the next tutorial, we’ll discuss creating an outline, which further helps align your research with your writing goals.

terms to know
Working Thesis
A preliminary thesis statement that helps the writer clarify for themself what they hope to do in the essay and guides them through the writing process.
Final Thesis
A thesis statement that gives the author’s purpose and provides an overview of the supporting evidence for their claim; this is the thesis statement that appears in the finished essay.

summary
In this lesson, you learned about formulating a thesis, progressing from an initial research question to thesis statement. A thesis statement conveys the main idea of an essay and should be debatable, specific, and supportable with evidence. You explored several strategies for developing a thesis statement, including problem/solution, cause/effect, and drawing a conclusion from available evidence formats, and learned the importance of refining a working thesis into a final thesis as research progresses. You also practiced evaluating and improving thesis statements based on clarity, specificity, and argumentative strength.

Source: This tutorial has been adapted from (1) OpenStax "Writing Guide". Access for free at openstax.org/books/writing-guide/pages/1-introduction. (2) Bay College Online Learning Department & Bay College Library "ENGL 101: Rhetoric & Composition". Access for free at oercommons.org/courses/engl-101-rhetoric-composition-by-bay-college. License: (1&2) Creative commons attribution 4.0 international. Accessed by January 2025.

REFERENCES

Bay College Online Learning Department, & Bay College Library. (2017). ENGL 101: Rhetoric & Composition (2nd ed.). Adapted from Writing for Success and edited by Amber Kinonen, Jennifer McCann, Todd McCann, and Erica Mead. Bay College.

Terms to Know
Final Thesis

A thesis statement that gives the author’s purpose and provides an overview of the supporting evidence for their claim; this is the thesis statement that appears in the finished essay.

Working Thesis

A preliminary thesis statement that helps the writer clarify for themself what they hope to do in the essay and guides them through the writing process.