Table of Contents |
Assumptions are beliefs held to be true without evidence. One key to judging the validity of sources is analysis. You already may be familiar with analysis, which involves looking at texts, media, or other artifacts to examine their individual parts and make interpretive claims about them. In the research process, analysis involves collecting data, deciding how you want to use that data (what are you looking for?), and applying those criteria to your data.
EXAMPLE
If you were looking at how the presence of social media has changed in television programs in the last 5 to 7 years, you would determine what shows you want to view and what patterns you want to study.As you analyze sources, you evaluate them in terms of your research needs. You will determine whether a source is acceptable or unacceptable, good or bad, trustworthy or biased. Although firm categories can be useful, you may find a more nuanced evaluation helpful as well. When you look for sources and evaluate them, begin with general questions such as these:
EXAMPLE
You may be writing about a particular historical event and come across a magazine article featuring a biased account of that event. If your purpose is to write a brief but accurate description of the event, then this account is of little use. But what if your purpose is to write a critical analysis of the ways in which misleading media coverage of an event has influenced public perception of it? Suddenly, the biased account becomes useful as a specific example of the media coverage you wish to analyze.A source’s value, therefore, is a function of your purpose for it. Labeling a source as good or bad, or truthful or misleading, doesn’t really evaluate its use to you as a researcher and writer; truthful sources can be used poorly, and misleading sources can be used effectively. What matters is whether the source fits your purpose. When evaluating a source, consider time (when was it judged to be true?) and perspective (who said it was true, and for what reason?).
To detect assumptions, actively look for statements that seem to take something for granted without explicit evidence, often using phrases like “obviously,” “everyone knows,” or “it goes without saying.” Critically analyze the logic gaps between presented evidence and conclusions, and use techniques like the “because” test, detailed below, to identify underlying beliefs that might be assumptions. Also, consider “what if” scenarios to challenge the validity of those assumptions.
Here are some key strategies to detect assumptions:
Generalizations are broad statements obtained by inference from combining specific cases.
To detect generalizations, look for phrases that indicate a broad statement about a group or category, often using words like “all,” “every,” “none,” “always,” “never,” “most,” or “everyone,” which suggest a sweeping claim without considering individual variations or exceptions within that group; also, consider whether the evidence provided adequately supports the broad statement being made.
Here are some ways to identify generalizations:
EXAMPLE
Generalization: “All teenagers are lazy.”How to evaluate generalizations:
Source: This tutorial has been adapted from (1) OpenStax "Writing Guide". Access for free at openstax.org/books/writing-guide/pages/1-introduction. (2) Achieving the Dream "English Composition". Access for free at https://quillbot.com/courses/english-composition-ii/. (3) UTSA "From College to Career: A Handbook for Student Writers". Access for free at utsa.pressbooks.pub/fromcollegetocareer/chapter/intellectual-standards-for-quality/. (4) Open Oregon "About Writing". Access for free at openoregon.pressbooks.pub/aboutwriting/chapter/types-of-writing-styles/. License: (1, 2, & 4) Creative commons attribution 4.0 international. (3) Creative commons attribution-sharealike 4.0 International. Accessed by January 2025.
REFERENCES
DePaul University. (n.d.). A guide to critical thinking. condor.depaul.edu/jmaresh/think/Critical_Thinking_print.html