Use Sophia to knock out your gen-ed requirements quickly and affordably. Learn more
×

Business Case & Project Justification

Author: Sophia

what's covered
In this lesson, you will explore the definition of a business case, along with the value a business case brings to a project. You will also explore the various components that go into a business case.

Specifically, this lesson will cover the following:

Table of Contents

1. What Is a Business Case?

before you start
Projects are started to help a business or organization solve a problem they have. This problem might be trying something new, improving something they already do, launching a new product, or fixing something that’s broken.

In the past, people thought a project was successful if it was finished on time and within budget (cost) and met the planned goals (scope). As identified in earlier lessons, these are known as triple constraints. Today, people have started to realize that just completing the project isn’t enough to call it a success. Now, businesses and other organizations, like nonprofits and government agencies, are looking more at the “value” a project provides. They want to know not just “what you built” but also “if it was worth the money and time spent.”

This idea of proving a project’s worth is called a business case. Even though it uses the word “business,” this idea is important for all types of organizations, including those that aren’t trying to make money. In these settings, it might be called a “case statement” or something similar.

key concept
A business case is a document used to explain why a project is needed. It looks at the current situation, describes what the organization wants to achieve in the future, and outlines the steps to get there. It also includes details about what the business needs, what stakeholders want, and the solutions and plans to help make these changes. Plus, it checks if these solutions are valuable.

Before a business case is made, a needs assessment is often done. A needs assessment is the process of identifying and analyzing gaps between the current state and desired outcomes to determine whether a project is necessary and what it should achieve. This assessment looks at the organization’s current abilities and environment to find the best ways to reach the desired future goals. Along with the business case, there is also a plan to manage and realize the benefits of the project. The business case is presented before the project life cycle, which you will learn more about in future lessons. According to the image below, it is considered “pre-project work,” which includes activities and analyses conducted before a project formally begins. This work helps to clarify the project’s goals, assess its feasibility, identify potential risks, and justify its value before resources are committed. Feasibility refers to the practicality and potential for the success of a proposed project or undertaking, and a feasibility plan addresses each of these elements.

A hand drawing a seesaw diagram with the word “Benefit” on the left and “Cost” on the right, balanced on a triangle.
Feasibility refers to the potential for the success of a project. In other words, how likely is it to meet the outcomes we want it to meet? Part of determining feasibility is putting together a feasibility plan, which addresses different elements such as the cost versus the benefit a project will bring.

terms to know
Business Case
A document used to explain why a project is needed.
Needs Assessment
The process of identifying and analyzing gaps between the current state and desired outcomes to determine whether a project is necessary and what it should achieve.
Feasibility
The practicality and potential for the success of a proposed project or undertaking.


2. The Value of a Business Case

Once a needs assessment is done, usually, a business case is written. The business case is important because it sets a potential project up for success. It does this in several ways.

First, it clarifies the problem or opportunity. By writing a business case, people are able to better understand the issue (or opportunity) and exactly what the company is trying to solve. This is advantageous because knowing exactly what problem we are addressing allows us to come up with viable solutions to solve it.

A business case also adds value because it allows the company to see what the expected benefits of the project will be and compare those to the expected costs. As you can imagine, if the costs outweigh the benefits, there’s really no reason to move forward with a project!

EXAMPLE


A man sitting on the roadside in front of a car with the hood up, talking on a phone and looking frustrated.
Cost-benefit analysis in project management isn’t that different from how we consider decisions in our personal lives. It is the comparison of, say, buying a new car to fixing your old one. We ask ourselves, “What will this cost, and what advantages or benefits will I get from this?”


Let’s suppose you decide you need more reliable transportation, so you purchase a brand-new SUV for $55,000. While you get the benefits of reliable transportation and a comfortable car, the monthly cost to maintain it, make your payments, and buy insurance is high, so the benefit you get doesn’t really work well with the cost. However, suppose you purchase a used, reliable car for $22,000, and you still get the benefits of reliable transportation and comfort, without the cost. In this case, the benefits probably outweigh the monthly cost. This is why companies look at the costs and benefits of a project—to get the most value for the money they are spending.

Another reason a business case is written is to make sure decisions that cost a company money have been well thought out, which results in reducing the financial risk to the company. In addition, writing a business case can help ensure the overall project will align with the goals of the company.

Overall, think of a business case as “why we should do this project” before time and money are committed to a project.

think about it
A business case is like a study to see if a project makes financial sense. It checks if the benefits are real by looking at what the business needs and comparing costs and benefits. This way, the money spent on the project can be justified.


3. The Components of a Business Case

You might wonder what aspects of a business case are included, with the goal of ultimately justifying why a company should move forward with a project. A business case usually includes the following:

Business Case Component Description
Executive Summary This is a brief overview of the document, which addresses each major section of the document.
Problem or Opportunity Statement This is a concise statement that addresses what issue the project will solve or the opportunity that will be taken advantage of.

Note: This statement is based on the needs assessment that was done prior to starting the business case.

Example: If a salon relies on manual booking processes, and it wants to create a mobile scheduling app, it might say, “The salon’s manual booking system causes scheduling errors, missed appointments, and extra work for staff. A mobile scheduling app is needed to streamline booking, reduce mistakes, and improve the client experience.”
Options This section lists all of the potential options and directions the company could take to solve the problem listed.
Recommended Solution This is where the company looks at the strengths and weaknesses of all options and justifies why it chooses a particular option.
Cost-Benefit Analysis What is the project expected to cost and what will the expected benefits be?

Example: Costs might include staff training and app development, while benefits might include fewer no-shows, which saves money, increases revenue, and saves staff time.
Risk Assessment While we get into risk analysis in more detail later in this course, for the purpose of the business case, some of the potential risks as they relate to project success or failure are addressed in this section.

Example: For our salon scheduling system, risks might include the clients’ resistance to using technology to schedule appointments.
Timelines The business case will address the expected timelines and milestones of the project.
Stakeholders This section of the business case will identify stakeholders; these are the people who have an interest in or are impacted by a project.

Example: The stakeholders for the salon might include clients, employees, and management.
Implementation Plan This is a brief overview that addresses the steps needed to put the plan into action.

Creating a business case is usually done before the project starts and, ultimately, leads to approvals to move forward with the project.

think about it
Suppose your car has been having issues and seems to be in the repair shop more than you’re able to drive it! How might you write a problem statement that addresses your need for a new car?

Since there are limited funds, companies must select projects carefully, and, ultimately, this is why we create a business case—to see what types of projects make the most sense to solve the problems we have or take advantage of opportunities in the market. Think of the business case as the starting point for a project, which outlines the project details at a high level.

terms to know
Problem or Opportunity Statement
A concise statement in a business case that addresses what issue the project will solve or the opportunity that will be taken advantage of.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
What the project is expected to cost and what the expected benefits will be.

summary
Today, you learned what a business case is, and the value it brings to an organization. A business case is a document created before a project begins to justify why the project is necessary by identifying a problem or opportunity, evaluating potential solutions and the feasibility of a project, and comparing expected costs to benefits. It helps reduce risk, align the project with organizational goals, and ensure smart financial decisions. The components of a business case include a problem (or opportunity) statement, a recommended solution, a cost-benefit analysis, a risk assessment, the stakeholders, the timeline, and the implementation plan. Ultimately, the business case helps organizations decide whether a project is worth pursuing.

Source: THIS TUTORIAL WAS AUTHORED BY SOPHIA LEARNING. PLEASE SEE OUR TERMS OF USE.

Terms to Know
Business Case

A document used to explain why a project is needed.

Cost-Benefit Analysis

What the project is expected to cost and what the expected benefits will be

Feasibility

The practicality and potential for the success of a proposed project or undertaking.

Needs Assessment

The process of identifying and analyzing gaps between the current state and desired outcomes to determine whether a project is necessary and what it should achieve.

Problem or Opportunity Statement

A concise statement in a business case that addresses what issue the project will solve or the opportunity that will be taken advantage of.