Use Sophia to knock out your gen-ed requirements quickly and affordably. Learn more
×

Apply L'Hopital's Rule to the Indeterminate Forms "∞ - ∞" and "∞ * 0"

Author: Sophia

what's covered
In this lesson, you will learn strategies to use when evaluating limits that have other indeterminate forms. Specifically, this lesson will cover:

Table of Contents

1. The Indeterminate Form ∞ – ∞

The form infinity minus infinity occurs when there is a difference between two expressions that are both tending toward infinity as x rightwards arrow a.

EXAMPLE

Evaluate the following limit: limit as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus of open parentheses 1 over x minus 1 over x squared close parentheses

Since 1 over x rightwards arrow infinity and 1 over x squared rightwards arrow infinity as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus, we have a limit of the form infinity minus infinity. One strategy is to write it as a single fraction, since this is a more familiar scenario.

Since 1 over x minus 1 over x squared equals x over x squared minus 1 over x squared equals fraction numerator x minus 1 over denominator x squared end fraction, we have the following:

limit as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus of open parentheses 1 over x minus 1 over x squared close parentheses Start with the limit that needs to be evaluated.
equals limit as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus of open parentheses fraction numerator x minus 1 over denominator x squared end fraction close parentheses Replace the expression with a single fraction.
equals fraction numerator c l o s e space t o space short dash 1 over denominator s m a l l space p o s i t i v e space n u m b e r end fraction As x approaches 0 from the right, x - 1 approaches -1 and x squared is a small positive number.
equals short dash infinity A negative number divided by a small positive number is a large negative number.

Thus, limit as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus of open parentheses 1 over x minus 1 over x squared close parentheses equals short dash infinity.

big idea
Many might think that a limit of the form infinity minus infinity should be 0 since you are “subtracting something from itself.” As we can see, this is not the case. Once we see infinity minus infinity produce another value, we will see why it is an indeterminate form.

watch
In this video, we'll evaluate limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of open parentheses square root of x squared plus 9 x end root minus x close parentheses.

Considering the results from these last two examples, it is clear now why infinity minus infinity is an indeterminate form. In one case, the result was short dash infinity, and in another case, the result was 9 over 2.


2. The Indeterminate Form ∞ ᐧ 0

The indeterminate form infinity times 0 is handled in one of two ways.

Loosely speaking, we can say that a limit of the form 1 over infinity will approach 0 and a limit of the form 1 over 0 will approach plus-or-minus infinity.

That said, we can treat “0” and “infinity” as reciprocals as far as limits are concerned.

This means that the indeterminate form infinity times 0 could be rewritten as either 0 over 0 or infinity over infinity, whichever is more convenient.

EXAMPLE

Evaluate the following limit: limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared e to the power of short dash 2 x end exponent

If we look at each factor separately, we see that x squared rightwards arrow infinity and e to the power of short dash 2 x end exponent rightwards arrow 0 as x rightwards arrow infinity. Thus, this limit has the form infinity times 0.

To rewrite, consider the fact that e to the power of short dash 2 x end exponent equals 1 over e to the power of 2 x end exponent, which means limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared e to the power of short dash 2 x end exponent equals limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared 1 over e to the power of 2 x end exponent equals limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared over e to the power of 2 x end exponent, which now has the form infinity over infinity.

To evaluate, use L’Hopital’s rule.

limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared over e to the power of 2 x end exponent Start with the limit that needs to be evaluated.
equals limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of fraction numerator 2 x over denominator 2 e to the power of 2 x end exponent end fraction Since x squared and e to the power of 2 x end exponent are differentiable and the limit has the form infinity over infinity, L’Hopital’s rule is used.
D open square brackets x squared close square brackets equals 2 x comma space D open square brackets e to the power of 2 x end exponent close square brackets equals 2 e to the power of 2 x end exponent
equals limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x over e to the power of 2 x end exponent Remove the common factor of 2.
equals limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of fraction numerator 1 over denominator 2 e to the power of 2 x end exponent end fraction Since limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x over e to the power of 2 x end exponent has the form infinity over infinity, continue to use L’Hopital’s rule.
D open square brackets x close square brackets equals 1 comma space D open square brackets e to the power of 2 x end exponent close square brackets equals 2 e to the power of 2 x end exponent
equals 0 Since the denominator grows very large as x rightwards arrow infinity, the limit is 0.

Thus, limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x squared e to the power of short dash 2 x end exponent equals 0.

big idea
If limit as x rightwards arrow a of f open parentheses x close parentheses times g open parentheses x close parentheses has the form infinity times 0, write limit as x rightwards arrow a offraction numerator f open parentheses x close parentheses over denominator open parentheses begin display style fraction numerator 1 over denominator g open parentheses x close parentheses end fraction end style close parentheses end fraction or limit as x rightwards arrow a of fraction numerator g open parentheses x close parentheses over denominator open parentheses begin display style fraction numerator 1 over denominator f open parentheses x close parentheses end fraction end style close parentheses end fraction, then use L'Hopital's rule.

watch
In this video, we’ll evaluate limit as x rightwards arrow 0 to the power of plus of x cubed times ln x.

watch
In this video, we’ll evaluate limit as x rightwards arrow infinity of x times sin open parentheses 1 over x close parentheses.

summary
In this lesson, you learned that with the addition of new indeterminate forms, more strategies need to be used. Specifically, you learned that for the indeterminate form bold infinity bold minus bold infinity, combining the fractions or rationalizing are the most common strategies; for the indeterminate form bold infinity bold times bold 0, rewriting the expression using reciprocals then using L’Hopital’s rule is the main strategy.

Source: THIS TUTORIAL HAS BEEN ADAPTED FROM CHAPTER 3 OF "CONTEMPORARY CALCULUS" BY DALE HOFFMAN. ACCESS FOR FREE AT WWW.CONTEMPORARYCALCULUS.COM. LICENSE: CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 3.0 UNITED STATES.