Use Sophia to knock out your gen-ed requirements quickly and affordably. Learn more
×

Analyzing Primary Sources

Author: Sophia

what's covered
The writing of history entails more than thinking about past events and creating stories based on those thoughts. Historians use evidence from the past, and the work of other historians, as the basis for their accounts.

This tutorial examines the sources that historians use, and how they use them, in three parts:

Table of Contents

1. How to Read a Primary Source

One reason that historians take secondary sources seriously is that primary sources cannot always be taken at face value. Oftentimes primary sources are biased. “Biased” sources aren’t “bad” sources. A biased source is simply one that has been created from a particular perspective; one that may not be objective, without prejudice or persuasive intent. When someone creates a primary source, that person’s background and personal beliefs, as well as his or her intended audience and purpose for writing, may introduce bias into that source. In addition to potential bias, the source may be received in different contexts. Sometimes there isn’t a clear idea on how to use a primary source.

The way to gain the most value from primary sources is to think about them critically and historically. Historians think about primary sources in a variety of ways, but one straightforward, easy-to-remember way to investigate these sources is to ask yourself the “Five Ws” (and one “H”):

  • Who created this source? Who is it about? Who is the audience?
  • What’s going on in the source? What’s the purpose?
  • Where was it created or presented?
  • When was it created?
  • Why does this source exist?
  • How is this source constructed? Does the ordering of the ideas tell you anything about points it may be trying to make?
These questions will help you to understand a source’s historical context, intended audience, perspective (“bias”), and purpose. Some of these questions can be tricky, such as those in the How category. This is why secondary sources are useful: They help you understand the context in which a source is written. In doing so they increase your familiarity with the author’s perspective and voice and make these questions less complicated.


2. Reading a Primary Source

Portrait of Frederick Douglass, ca. 1879.
To learn how to read a primary source, let’s consider a speech by Frederick Douglass, who was born into slavery and later became a prominent opponent of slavery and an advocate of Black equality at the time of the Civil War.

This selection is from “What the Black Man Wants.” Douglass gave this speech in April of 1865, during the annual meeting of the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society in Boston.

Frederick Douglass, “What the Black Man Wants”

“I have had but one idea for the last three years to present to the American people, and the phraseology in which I clothe it is the old abolition phraseology. I am for the ‘immediate, unconditional, and universal’ enfranchisement of the Black man, in every State in the Union. [Loud applause.] Without this, his liberty is a mockery; without this, you might as well almost retain the old name of slavery for his condition; for in fact, if he is not the slave of the individual master, he is the slave of society, and holds his liberty as a privilege, not as a right. He is at the mercy of the mob, and has no means of protecting himself.”

At first glance, this seems like a straightforward request for the right to vote to be extended to African Americans, many of whom were formerly enslaved. Douglass indicates that he had advocated this cause for at least 3 years. However, when you consider his words in the context of the Civil War and militant abolitionism, other facets of Douglass’s argument and motives come into focus.

Douglass made this speech in April of 1865, at the end of the Civil War. Two years earlier, on January 1, 1863, President Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, which signaled the end of slavery in the United States. By April of 1865, major fighting in the Civil War had subsided and, like many Americans, Douglass wanted to know what was in store for those who had been freed. Although he supported the Emancipation Proclamation, freedom was not enough for him. By insisting on “the ‘immediate, unconditional, and universal’ enfranchisement of the Black man”, Douglass asserted that the right to vote for African Americans must accompany the end of slavery in the United States.

In making this speech to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, which was among the most prominent abolitionist groups, Douglass attempted to enlist the support of abolitionists for Black suffrage. This is evident in his reference to “the old abolition phraseology.” Prior to the Civil War, militant abolitionists agitated for the “immediate, unconditional, and universal” end of slavery in the United States. Now, in April of 1865, with slavery ending and Union victory assured, Douglass urged abolitionists to apply the same rhetoric (and the reasoning behind it) in support of Black voting rights. Contemporary speech transcripts indicate “Loud Applause” during Douglass’s statement, suggesting that many in the Massachusetts abolitionist community supported this cause.

On the surface, Douglass’s argument in favor of Black voting rights seems straightforward. When the context and audience are taken into account, however, a clearer and more complete picture comes into view. The time at which it was given is crucial to understanding Douglass’s speech: it reveals his hopes for a national post-war policy. By addressing an abolitionist audience, Douglass attempted to mobilize a mass movement on behalf of Black suffrage.

try it
Try to apply the Five Ws to the political cartoon below. It addresses another issue that we will examine during this course: immigration. First, answer as many of the Five W questions as you can by referring only to the image. Next, use the Internet to find answers to other questions you might have.

term to know
Militant Abolitionism
Advocated for the complete and immediate elimination of slavery from the United States on moral grounds.


3. How to Think like a Historian

You can begin to think like a historian by applying the Five Ws to primary and secondary sources. Primary sources can be complex, so use historical thinking and critical thinking skills when examining them. Critical thinking is hard to define, but it fundamentally indicates the use of a clear, self-directed, and evidence-based process to form a judgment on a topic. In other words, when creating accounts of the past, historians must take a responsible approach to judging available evidence and create a narration based on it.

One way that historians do this is by thinking historically about an event and its related primary sources. This can be accomplished through a variety of intellectual channels. An easy one to remember is to think in terms of the Five Cs (Andrews & Burke, 2007):

  • Change Over Time: History happens over a period of time. During any given period of time, people, events, and ideas can change.
  • Context: Think about historical events and about primary source evidence in terms of their greater context. Anything you read that was written in the past was not created in a vacuum. Similarly, anything that happened in the past was not isolated from the social, cultural, economic, and political setting in which it occurred. That context informs the ways we should think about historical events, or about primary source evidence, today.
  • Causality: All events have multiple causes and effects. For example, the American Civil War did not occur out of nowhere. Before the first shot was fired, a long history of conflict and debate set the stage. Primary sources were also caused by something or somethings.
  • Contingency: This means that everything is related. Similar to context and causality, the historian understands that nothing happens on its own. Historians think about how later events or historical trends are influenced by earlier ones. In the same way, historians think about the ways a primary source is related to other primary sources and identify connections between multiple pieces of evidence and historical scenarios.
  • Complexity: We live in a complex world. For example, no single cause started the Revolutionary War. Historians understand this and create historical narratives that reflect a world of different meanings and perspectives.
term to know
Critical Thinking
Clear, self-directed, and evidence-based judgment on a topic.

summary
In this lesson, you learned how to read a primary source. It begins with asking careful questions about authorship, audience, purpose, and context. You then practiced reading a primary source, seeing how Frederick Douglass’s words gained fuller meaning when placed in the setting of the Civil War and Black suffrage. Finally, you learned how to think like a historian, using the Five Ws and Five Cs to judge evidence thoughtfully and build more complete and objective interpretations of the past.

Source: This tutorial has been adapted from Openstax "U.S. History". Access for free at openstax.org/details/books/us-history. LICENSE: CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL. Accessed by January 2017.

REFERENCES

Andrews, T & Burke, F. (2007, Jan). What Does It Mean to Think Historically? Ret Oct 2016, from bit.ly/2i1vENK

Douglass, F. (1865). What the Black Man Wants. Ret Mar 10, 2017, from teachingamericanhistory.org/document/what-the-black-man-wants-2/

Attributions
Terms to Know
Critical Thinking

Clear, self-directed, and evidence-based judgment on a topic.

Militant Abolitionism

Advocated for the complete and immediate elimination of slavery from the United States on moral grounds.

Primary Source

Firsthand accounts/evidence from the time period that a historian is writing about or studying.

Secondary Source

Pieces of work that contain analyses of primary sources that relate to events that have already taken place in the past.